Imagine a world where the unseen hands behind the scenes hold as much power as the stars themselves. For the first time ever, the Oscars are shining a well-deserved spotlight on casting, a vital yet often overlooked aspect of filmmaking. But here’s where it gets controversial: does recognizing casting with its own award truly elevate the craft, or does it risk overshadowing other essential elements of filmmaking?
In the world of major Hollywood productions, the magic behind iconic films often begins long before cameras start rolling — with the visionary work of casting directors. An excellent example is the two-part film adaptation of 'Wicked' that follows the beloved 'Wizard of Oz.' Behind this success were talented professionals meticulously selecting the right actors, the people who set the stage for what became a blockbuster event, well ahead of any filming.
Bernard Telsey, a prominent figure in casting, explains, “Our role is to know the pool of talent out there or to discover new actors who might not yet be on everyone’s radar.” This process is crucial because, as he points out, casting is not just about picking actors; it's about finding the right ones, sometimes taking significant risks with unfamiliar faces.
Next year, the industry will finally acknowledge the importance of this role on cinema’s biggest stage. The Oscars will introduce a separate category dedicated to achievement in casting, a move welcomed by professionals who believe this recognition is long overdue. The 98th Academy Awards will broadcast live on ABC on March 15, 2026, and many hope this will bring greater awareness and respect to casting directors.
Telsey shares that many find it difficult to understand what casting directors do because their work remains largely behind closed doors. “This addition will help strengthen our profession and highlight the artistry involved,” he says.
While the Emmys have three categories for casting, and the Critics Choice Awards have also recently introduced a casting award, the industry still lacks acknowledgment from other major awards like the Golden Globes or the Tony Awards. Yet, the art of casting often feels invisible because when it’s done well, you hardly notice it; it’s seamless and natural, much like magic.
Destiny Lilly, president of the Casting Society with over 1,200 members, points out that much of what casting directors do occurs early in the production process — long before filming or rehearsals begin — which is why recognition has taken time to catch up.
Telsey’s own career spans from theater to screen, with credits on films such as 'Mary Poppins Returns' and 'Kiss of the Spider Woman,' as well as acclaimed TV series like 'The Gilded Age' and 'Only Murders in the Building.' His theater background includes casting Tony Award-winning shows like 'Kinky Boots' and 'Hairspray.'
One of his most challenging projects was the 'Wicked' film adaptations, where his team had to cast hundreds of roles spanning multiple continents over more than a year. Although it might seem obvious in hindsight that Cynthia Erivo was perfect as Elphaba and Ariana Grande was ideal as Glinda, these decisions carried a fair amount of risk and were not made lightly.
Telsey remarks, “You don’t really see how perfect it is until actors get in the room. That’s when you feel the ‘this is it’ moment — when it becomes clear there are no better choices.”
To keep up with the vast array of talent, Telsey dedicates several nights weekly to theater performances and weekends to films and television, constantly searching for new faces. His team meets regularly to share insights, review performances, and recommend breakout stars.
The process begins with conversations with directors, writers, and producers to understand their vision, akin to how a costume designer needs to know the fabric and color palette available. Telsey emphasizes the importance of matching the right actor to the right project, a process that requires deep intuition and a keen eye.
Recently, Tiffany Little Canfield suggested comedian Bill Burr for a notable Broadway revival of David Mamet’s 'Glengarry Glen Ross,' which marked Burr’s debut on stage. Her choice proved inspired, as Mamet’s sharp dialogue suited Burr’s style perfectly. This exemplifies how casting can bring unexpected talents into the spotlight and open doors for those who haven't yet had their theatrical break.
Despite some stereotypes, Telsey argues that the divide between film, television, and theater acting is a myth. “Good acting transcends the medium,” he asserts. “Actors like Glenn Close have proven it’s possible to be equally compelling on stage and screen, often earning nominations in both areas.” Over the last two decades, the boundary between these disciplines has blurred significantly, reflecting the versatility required of modern actors.
Telsey’s journey into casting began with the musical 'Rent,' which he humorously describes as an unlikely project that changed his life. With the evolution of technology, the ease of online auditions, and the rise of global film markets, his work has become more complex and fast-paced. The need to scout and cast broadly, often with limited time and shrinking budgets, keeps casting directors on their toes.
In summary, as the industry begins to officially honor casting through prestigious awards, one must ask: does this recognition truly reflect the value casting brings to storytelling? Or does it risk creating distance between the craft and the audience, making the invisible yet essential art of casting more celebrated only behind-the-scenes? Share your thoughts — do you believe casting deserves this spotlight, or is it just the beginning of further complexities in appreciating what makes movies memorable?
