A shocking contract decision has redefined the Detroit Tigers' offseason before it even begins. Jack Flaherty's unexpected move has left fans and analysts alike scratching their heads.
Throughout the 2025 season, Tigers fans had a rollercoaster ride with Flaherty. He showed glimpses of brilliance, but his inconsistency was a constant source of frustration. Despite a solid 2024 campaign and a well-received re-signing, Flaherty's performance took a nosedive, ending the year with a less-than-impressive 4.64 ERA. One week he'd dominate, and the next, he'd be shelled by weaker opponents.
Flaherty's two-year contract, worth $35 million with a player option for 2026, included a potential $10 million bonus for the second year, contingent on him making 15 regular-season starts. He achieved this benchmark in June, setting himself up for a potential $20 million payday in 2026.
Contrary to some speculations, Flaherty has decided to stay with the Tigers and exercise his player option. Jeff Passan, who initially predicted Flaherty would explore free agency, broke the news first. Detroit Tigers' right-hander Jack Flaherty has opted to stay put, sources confirm to ESPN. He will return to Detroit for the 2026 season, where he has been a key part of the team for the past two years.
Flaherty somewhat redeemed himself in a crucial game against the Mariners in the ALDS. Despite a rocky start, he pitched two gutsy innings, showcasing his determination and love for the organization. However, it's hard not to ponder the alternatives the Tigers could have pursued with the $20 million they'll now be paying him.
While Flaherty is a likable player, he hasn't lived up to the expectations of a No. 2 starter. If his performance in 2026 mirrors this season, the Tigers might be paying a premium for his services. Passan's initial argument for Flaherty declining his option was based on his impressive strikeout numbers (188, with a 10.51 K/9), but Flaherty evidently didn't see it that way.
Tigers fans always felt that getting more than $20 million from another team was unlikely for Flaherty. Now, with his decision to stay, the Tigers' budget for the offseason has become even tighter, especially if they opt for a more conservative spending approach.
If Flaherty can turn it around next season, everyone will be cheering for him. But if he struggles, fans will undoubtedly question the decision and wonder about the other players their money could have attracted.
And this is the part most people miss: Flaherty's decision has set the tone for the Tigers' offseason. Will they continue to be conservative spenders, or will they surprise us all and make some bold moves? Only time will tell. What are your thoughts on Flaherty's decision? Do you think he made the right call, or should he have explored free agency? Let us know in the comments!
